Question:
Why does the Canadian P.M. insult Chinese Canadians?
anonymous
2006-06-23 23:52:37 UTC
Why does Stephen Harper harp on their origin as coolies, imported to build the C.P.R. Does he think this will please them and make them vote for him?
Five answers:
?
2006-06-24 06:58:52 UTC
Are you sure you've got that right? Harper has plans to issue a formal apology on behalf of the Canadian government for the head tax that was unjustly imposed on Chinese immigrants for decades, in a transparent attempt to keep them out of the country even as they were providing essential labor.
old lady
2006-06-24 19:36:30 UTC
Stephen Harper was responding to a concern by the Chinese-Canadian population, that their ancestors were unfairly taxed. That is, they had to pay a head tax to come to Canada. This was 100 years ago, so it isn't anything recent. But they wanted redress, and apologies for the Chinese exclusion act that followed, and has long since been repealed.

Stephen Harper gave them that apology.

Why did he refer to them as coolies? Because that's what they were, and that's why they were imported to Canada in the first place -- to build the CPR. Most of them went back to China when the CPR was complete, some stayed and found new lives for themselves. In those days, they were very restricted as to occupations. They could not work in the mines (underground) so many panned for gold, and very successfully, I might add. In those days, the professions were closed to them, so their major opportunity was running restaurants and laundries.

In later years, these prohibitions were repealed, and Chinese-Canadians were able to enter the professions, to become doctors, lawyers, pharmacists,or whatever they wanted.

Stephen Harper also celebrated that fact in his talk.

Canadians of Chinese origin today are firmly enmeshed in the fabric of Canada. They may be found in every walk of life, in every occupation, and in the House of Commons, where they are elected members.
XYZ
2006-06-24 13:41:23 UTC
Racists and anti-immigrants (not that I'm suggesting they're the same people) tend to vote for his party. I guess he's trying to appeal to the 'grass roots' of his party. Chinese Canadians, by and large, tend to vote Liberal anyway, so I guess he wagers that he won't lose too many votes.



By the way, I hadn't heard Harper say any such thing but it wouldn't surprise me.



-------



edit: peter, that actually doesn't sound too negative, what you've described. I can't believe I'm defending Harper, but 'righting the wrongs', recognising the role that Chinese-Canadians played in our early history and atoning for past misdeeds seems like a good thing, as opposed to 'burying it in the past and forgetting it ever happened'.
sportin_jenny
2006-06-25 05:39:26 UTC
He said he was sorry on behalf of the country for the Chinese head tax, and each surving person who had to pay the head tax is going to get 20,000 from the government...that doesn't sound insulting to me
akg
2006-06-28 16:08:07 UTC
no one cares what the candian pm thinks.

I'm canadian, and even i ignore him.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...